Good morning ladies. I need help on something, and since your opinions are so trusted by moi, I thought who better to ask?
My Dad, a Real Estate Broker for 25 years, is semi-retiring and moving his office home. He offered me the antique oak table that he used as a conference/desk table for the last 25 years. I think I should take it as
1. it's a lot nicer than my dining table
2. He sat and it for 25 years and conducted millions of dollars of business at it so it's sentimental
3. It's a lot nicer than my dining table.
Here's a {very small} picture of it. Please click to enlarge.
Problem is, there are no chairs to match and my current chairs are way too country. So I'm chair hunting. In my dream world, I would buy chairs like these without the worry of PB&J getting smashed into their crevices:
Or these lovelies.... which would be stained and ruined within minutes of putting them in my house:
Or even these, whose sublime striped padded seats would become plaid, with ketchup being the other stripe:
So basically, I need
solid wood chairs. And I need them cheap. Like no more than $60 per chair, max. Kind of limits your options, you know? But, I found these at jcpenney.com. Each style comes in antique black or antique white. I think black might look better against the table finish, but I have an antique white hutch, seen
here, in the same room. So what I am asking is, do either of these chairs have the character or shape to compliment the table? And what color should I do, black or white? I am not into getting wood to match the table... I like the mismatched eclectic look. If neither of these chairs look like they would work, feel free to tell me that too. But I haven't found any solid wood chairs anywhere else for this price {2 for $129 on sale} so I think I should try and make it work. Also, I could possibly repaint my hutch black {would look really cool with all my white dishes} and then get the black chairs. Not sure... Here are your choices:
#1 Montclair - Sheaf back chair. The turned legs are nice counterpoints to the turned trestle legs of the table. Remember, antique black or antique white. Here's the link to the chairs
http://www3.jcpenney.com/jcp/X6.aspx?DeptID=57087&CatID=57916&GrpTyp=PRD&ItemID=113f567&attrtype=&attrvalue=&CMID=57087%7c57092%7c57916&Fltr=&Srt=&QL=F&IND=9&CmCatId=5708757092579162. Bedford chair. The slight urn shape in the back panel would also reference the turned legs of the antique table.... not sure if the top horizontal bar would look as good, but to me these remind me of Pottery Barn chairs.
http://www3.jcpenney.com/jcp/X6.aspx?DeptID=57087&CatID=57916&GrpTyp=PRD&ItemID=113f558&attrtype=&attrvalue=&CMID=57087%7c57092%7c57916&Fltr=&Srt=&QL=F&IND=4&CmCatId=570875709257916Thank you so much for your opinion!!!
**Edited to add: the dining room wall seen in the hutch post {linked above} is now going to be Svelte Sage. Don't know if that makes it more clear with the chair choices or more confusing. Just thought I'd tell you we reached a paint conclusion and the red wall is no more. It will be lovely in a deep sage.